The Canadiens lost 3-1 to the Rangers at Madison Square Garden on Monday night, and the score only tells part of the story. The first line barely showed up, the power play went 0-for-4, and Montreal did not create real pressure until the goalie was pulled with five minutes left.

It was the second straight regulation loss after Saturday’s 4-1 defeat to Colorado. Montreal sits at 12-5-4 with 28 points, while the Rangers won their third in a row. The shots finished 26-25 for New York, so this was close on paper. It did not feel close for most of the night.

Danault Scored First, Then Cuylle Answered Twice

It was scoreless until 7:59 of the second period, when Phillip Danault tipped the puck past Joonas Korpisalo for a 1-0 lead, with Lane Hutson and Noah Dobson on the assists. The lead lasted less than two minutes. Will Cuylle deflected a shot in at 9:47 to make it 1-1.

The goal that changed the game came at 19:03 of the second. Montreal was on the power play after a Rangers interference penalty, and Adam Fox started a long outlet pass the other way that sent Cuylle in. He beat Jacob Fowler with a wrist shot, shorthanded, for his second of the night and a 2-1 Rangers lead. A power play that should have pushed Montreal ahead ended with the Canadiens trailing.

Scott Morrow made it 3-1 at 6:44 of the third with a wrist shot from Noah Laba’s pass, his first goal as a Ranger. Fowler was screened on the play, and the Canadiens never found a way back.

The First Line Disappeared

Our read after watching the game live: this was a very bad night for the Canadiens’ top line, and the effort was not there. The play-by-play supports that. Juraj Slafkovský had the only two shots on goal from the Nick Suzuki, Cole Caufield and Slafkovský line until the final five minutes, and both came within five seconds of each other in the first period.

Caufield did not record a single shot attempt, on goal, missed or blocked, until 15:52 of the third period. Suzuki’s first shot on goal came at 17:34, with 2:26 left. Caufield’s first came at 18:24, with 1:36 left. In all, the line finished with seven shots on goal, and five of them came after Montreal pulled Fowler for the extra attacker with 5:13 to play.

Those minutes came with a big advantage: two Rangers penalties (Kartye and Cuylle for high-sticking) gave Montreal two power plays, and the empty net added another skater. That is when the top line finally looked dangerous. It was far too late, and it is not the version of the line this team needs for the first 55 minutes.

The Power Play Went 0-for-4, and Only Four Shots Came

Montreal had four power plays: Robertson’s interference in the second period, Zibanejad’s cross-checking early in the third, and the two high-sticking penalties late. They did not score on any of them. Across the four, the Canadiens recorded four shots on goal, and all four came in the last two and a half minutes of the game.

The early third-period power play also ended badly. Dobson took an interference penalty at 2:26, 1:29 into the advantage, and Montreal had to kill the Rangers’ power play right after. For a team that needs its man advantage to be a weapon, this was a night of wasted chances, and the shorthanded goal against made it worse.

Fowler’s Road Streak Ends, but Not All of It Was on Him

Fowler stopped 23 of 26 shots (.885) in his first regulation loss since October 8 against Nashville. Before Monday he was 9-0-2 over his previous 11 games, and he had won all five of his road starts (Chicago, Winnipeg, St. Louis, Toronto and Boston). Korpisalo stopped 24 of 25 (.960) for the Rangers.

The public game-card model gave Fowler a game score of -1.60, with 1.40 expected goals against on the shots he faced versus the three he allowed. That is a model estimate, and it is harsh when two of the three goals came through traffic, a deflection and a screened shot. Still, he will want the shorthanded goal back.

The Third Pair and Danault’s Line Carried the Play

A game-score model built from public tracking data shows who drove the game. The best game scores for Montreal belonged to Danault (2.27), Zachary Bolduc (1.51), Arber Xhekaj (1.41), Alexandre Texier (1.39) and Adam Engström (0.95). The worst belonged to Caufield (-1.18), Slafkovský (-0.72), Dobson (-0.54), Suzuki (-0.41) and Hutson (-0.30).

On ice, the gap was just as clear. Caufield’s shifts produced 0.16 expected goals for and 0.74 against. Slafkovský and Suzuki were around 0.22 for and 0.55 against. Arber Xhekaj and Engström, the third pair, were at 0.62 and 0.54 for, against only 0.14 and 0.15. Montreal’s third pair and Danault’s line outplayed the top six, which is the opposite of what the team expects.

A deserve-to-win model, which weighs the quality of every chance, gave the Rangers a slight edge at 54.5 percent to 45.5 for Montreal. The Canadiens had more total shot attempts (52-49), but at five-on-five the Rangers led 37-34. The same model still gives Montreal about 90 percent playoff odds after the game.

A Milestone for Hutson on a Losing Night

Hutson’s assist on Danault’s goal was the 144th of his career. That makes him fourth among Original Six defencemen under 23 in career assists, behind Bobby Orr (272), Ray Bourque (199) and Brian Leetch (164). He played 28:38 in the game, the most of any Canadien.

Next Up

The Canadiens now play two games in two nights. They visit the New Jersey Devils on Wednesday, November 18 at 7:30 PM ET, then go to Carolina on Thursday, November 19 at 7:00 PM ET, and return home to face Philadelphia on Saturday, November 21 at 7:00 PM ET. With the back-to-back, our read is that both goalies will play, but the Canadiens have not confirmed it.

Sources: NHL game data, MoneyPuck, HockeyStatCards (Natural Stat Trick data), RDS (milestone context).

Get the HABSHQ Newsletter in Your Inbox

Every Monday, the HABSHQ newsletter brings you the full Canadiens, Rocket, Lions and prospects report, our takes, the stats of the week and the preview of the week ahead, straight to your inbox. It is free.

QR code to subscribe to the HABSHQ newsletter
Scan with your phone to subscribe

Get the Habs week in your inbox

Free weekly newsletter from HABSHQ.

More from HABSHQ

Watch the analysis

Coach Frenchy breaks down every Canadiens game live on the Hockey Nation Live Show, with the lines, the numbers and the plays that mattered.

Watch on YouTube

About Coach Frenchy

Coach Frenchy (Pierre) hosts the Hockey Nation Live Show, the daily live Canadiens and NHL commentary show on YouTube. HABSHQ is where he brings the lines, the numbers and the prospects together in one place.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

AboutNewsletterContactTerms and Disclaimer