The Canadiens are 12-5-4 with 28 points after 21 games, and one problem keeps showing up when they lose: an anemic power play. On Monday in New York it cost them the game. Behind it sit two more concerns, a first line that has stopped scoring on the road and two core players, Noah Dobson and Juraj Slafkovský, who are playing well below their level.

The Power Play Cost Them the Game in New York

The winning goal against the Rangers was scored by Will Cuylle while the Canadiens were on the power play. The shorthanded goal came eight seconds after a Canadiens shot missed the net at the end of the second period, and it made the score 2-1. In the third period, trailing 3-1, the Canadiens got two more power plays with the goalie pulled for a 6-on-4. They scored on neither. A goal on either one would have turned the last minutes into a one-goal game.

The Canadiens finished 0 for 4 with four shots on those four power plays. Over the season they are 8 for 64, a 12.5 percent success rate that ranks 31st in the NHL. Only Ottawa is worse. The franchise record low for a full season is reported to be 13.2 percent, which means Montreal is on pace to break it.

The five-on-four numbers show how little the unit gives the team. In 21 games the Canadiens have scored five power-play goals at five-on-four and allowed three shorthanded goals, a net gain of only two. A power play is supposed to give a team a clear edge over the other side’s penalty kill, and Montreal’s has barely produced one.

Head coach Martin St-Louis does not hide from it. “We’re losing a lot of momentum with the power play,” he said after the game, and he described the pressure that builds on the unit the longer it goes without scoring. Suzuki said the problem is more on the players than on the structure.

So why is it happening? A few weeks ago St-Louis pointed to the speed of execution: the unit has lost the speed it needs to score. Our read adds a second reason, and it has a name. Slafkovský scored 15 of his 30 goals last season on the power play, many of them off plays built from the wall to the goal line and into the slot. This season he has no power-play goal and only four power-play points, in three games out of 21. The Canadiens now play on the outside and move the puck along the perimeter, and opponents have adjusted. A power play that never attacks the middle is easy to kill. Until the puck goes back from the wall to the goal line to the slot at speed, the numbers will not move.

The First Line Has Gone Quiet on the Road

Nick Suzuki has five points in six road games, but four of them came in one night in Pittsburgh on Oct. 3. In the other five road games he has one point, a goal in Washington. Since he returned from injury he has played three road games, in Toronto, Boston and New York, with no points and three shots. Slafkovský has no points in those three games either. Only Cole Caufield has produced, with a goal and an assist.

PlayerRoad GPGAPTSSOG
Nick Suzuki30003
Cole Caufield31129
Juraj Slafkovský30008

Last three road games, Nov. 7 at Toronto, Nov. 12 at Boston and Nov. 16 at New York.

Here is what the line did with the three players on the ice together in those games: it scored two goals and gave up two. One of the goals came on the power play, so at five-on-five the count was one for and two against, and both goals against came with Dobson on the ice. The team won in Toronto and Boston because the depth lines scored. Kreider scored in Toronto, and Anderson and Evans scored in Boston. On Monday that cushion was not there, and the first line produced nothing until the Canadiens were pulling the goalie. Caufield did not take a shot attempt until the 15:52 mark of the third period.

Why does it happen on the road? The home team gets the last change, so the opposing coach can put his best defensive pair against the Canadiens’ top line every shift. At home St-Louis can pick his matchups. On the road the line has to beat those players, and so far it has not.

Dobson’s Defensive Decisions Are Costing the Canadiens

Noah Dobson had his worst game of the season on Monday. He finished a minus-2 with one shot on net, and he was on the ice for all three Rangers goals. He has gone 56 games without scoring, counting 21 this season, 22 at the end of last season and 13 playoff games. His last goal was on Feb. 26, 2026. This season he has nine assists, 42 shots and no goals.

The scoring drought is not the real problem. The real problem is the quality of his decisions in the defensive zone, especially on two-on-ones. Our read from watching: on Cuylle’s shorthanded goal, Dobson let Cuylle take the shot when he should have closed on him. The other attacker was already covered by a teammate who had backchecked, so Dobson had no reason to stay back. A defenseman has to read that situation in half a second, and he has been getting it wrong in recent games.

That matters because of who he is. Dobson scored 70 points in 2023-24, and the Canadiens signed him to an eight-year contract worth $9.5 million a year. He is a 6-foot-4 defenseman who is paid to be one of the best on the team in both ends, and we have not even talked about the physical side of his game yet. Right now he is far from the Dobson of last season, and farther from the one who put up 70 points.

Slafkovský Has Lost His Confidence and His Drive

Juraj Slafkovský has two goals in 21 games from 50 shots, one point in his last five games, and only 19 hits. That is not the player Montreal knows. Our read is that he has not been the same since his fight with Tampa Bay’s Brandon Hagel in last spring’s playoffs. Since then he has lost his confidence and his play-driving.

The problems are visible in the details. His decisions with the puck are poor, he is not involved enough on the forecheck, and his passing has been his biggest weakness this season. He also lost his temper in each of the last two games, once with the coach and on Monday with his captain. For the first time in Montreal, the pressure seems to be catching up with him. A winger who scored 30 goals a year ago and plays on the first line cannot be a passenger, and the team needs the old Slafkovský back quickly.

Arber Xhekaj and Danault Were the Best Canadiens on the Ice

Arber Xhekaj was more than his numbers. He had a solid first period and made two excellent plays where he drove to the net and almost scored. He is playing with much more confidence, he is more involved in the offence, and he protects the front of the net better. He finished the night with three shots and four hits. Jayden Struble was traded to Nashville on Oct. 9, and our read is that it removed the worry about becoming a healthy scratch. Whatever the reason, Xhekaj is playing very well this season, and Monday was the best game of his career.

Phillip Danault scored the Canadiens’ only goal and had five shots, but it was his driving of the line all night that stood out. With Bolduc and Texier, Danault’s line was the best on the ice. He has two goals in his last three games, he looks faster this season, and he continues to dominate on the penalty kill.

Injuries Could Sink the Season

The loss to the Rangers was the first game without Chris Kreider, Josh Anderson and Mike Matheson in the lineup together, and the Canadiens looked flat with no energy. These are experienced players and leaders, and the team is trying to patch the lineup with what it has. On Monday night that was not good enough. The six bottom-six forwards combined for only three shots on goal, and a team cannot win when its depth gives that little.

Those three players bring a specific role that the Canadiens have counted on since the start of the season, and it is missed. Two of them were part of the depth scoring that carried the road wins: Kreider scored in Toronto, and Anderson scored in Boston on a pass from Matheson. Ivan Demidov has played only two of the team’s 21 games and Matheson nine. With the injuries, Owen Beck is in the lineup and Adam Engström plays on the third pair.

If the absences are short, the Canadiens can get through them. If they last into December while the first line stays quiet, there will be nobody left to cover, and that is how the injuries could sink the season.

The Offense Has Dried Up

The Canadiens scored 3.47 goals a game over their first 17 games. In the last four they have scored two a game: one goal against Minnesota, five in Boston, then one against Colorado and one against the Rangers. Three of the last four games ended with a single goal, and the team is 1-2-1 in that stretch. You are not going to win games with one goal.

The main reason is that too many forwards have gone cold at the same time. Juraj Slafkovský has one goal in his last 18 games and none in the last 12. Jake Evans has one goal in his last 11 games, Alexandre Texier one in his last 13, Oliver Kapanen one in the 14 games he has played, and Zachary Bolduc one in his last nine. These are the players the Canadiens need to score after the first line, and when they all go quiet together the team has no answer on most nights.

Special teams make it worse. The power play should be the tool that creates goals when five-on-five play is tight, but it has scored once in its last 14 chances. The penalty kill has allowed five goals on its last 17 kills, a success rate of 70.6 percent. Over the last five games the Canadiens scored one power-play goal and gave up three. A team that is not scoring at even strength cannot afford to lose the special-teams battle every night, and right now that is the second problem next to the first line.

Next Up: A Road Back-to-Back Is the Test

The Canadiens play at New Jersey on Wednesday, Nov. 18 at 7:30 PM ET and at Carolina on Thursday, Nov. 19 at 7:00 PM ET, then return home on Saturday, Nov. 21 at 7:00 PM ET against Philadelphia. Two road games in two nights is the test for both the first line and the power play.

Sources: NHL game data; TVA Sports (franchise power play record); The Athletic; postgame comments from Martin St-Louis and Nick Suzuki.

Get the HABSHQ Newsletter in Your Inbox

Every Monday, the HABSHQ newsletter brings you the full Canadiens, Rocket, Lions and prospects report, our takes, the stats of the week and the preview of the week ahead, straight to your inbox. It is free.

QR code to subscribe to the HABSHQ newsletter
Scan with your phone to subscribe

Get the Habs week in your inbox

Free weekly newsletter from HABSHQ.

More from HABSHQ

Watch the analysis

Coach Frenchy breaks down every Canadiens game live on the Hockey Nation Live Show, with the lines, the numbers and the plays that mattered.

Watch on YouTube

About Coach Frenchy

Coach Frenchy (Pierre) hosts the Hockey Nation Live Show, the daily live Canadiens and NHL commentary show on YouTube. HABSHQ is where he brings the lines, the numbers and the prospects together in one place.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

AboutNewsletterContactTerms and Disclaimer