Update, November 22: The Canadiens announced on their website and on X that they have loaned forward Brett Berard and defenseman David Reinbacher to the Laval Rocket. Our read is that this is a short, one-game move and that either player could be recalled after the Rocket play Calgary on Sunday, but the club has not said so.

Canadiens personnel move graphic: Brett Berard and David Reinbacher loaned to the Laval Rocket
Source: Montreal Canadiens (canadiens.com and X)

David Reinbacher played 10:50 against Philadelphia on Saturday night, and the Canadiens lost 4-3. The score is not the story. With Reinbacher on the ice at five-on-five, Montreal outshot the Flyers 6-3, outscored them 2-0 and controlled just over 75 percent of the expected goals. For a young defenseman playing his fourth NHL game, that is a very good night, and it puts a bigger question back on the table: is he the right-side defenseman the Habs drafted him to be?

Montreal outshot Philadelphia 23-20 in the game. Reinbacher finished plus-2 with two shots on goal, three hits and a blocked shot in 17 shifts. He did not take over the game and he did not need to. He was calm, he was in position, and the team played better when he was out there. That matters because his whole value to this organization is bigger than one game.

Why the Habs Drafted Him Fifth Overall

Reinbacher was taken with the fifth pick in 2023 because of the position he plays. Right-shot defensemen with top-four ability are scarce, and general manager Kent Hughes said on draft night that Montreal might not have taken him where they did if he had shot left. That is the key to the whole story. The Habs were not choosing the best player on the board. They were choosing the piece they could not easily find anywhere else.

That is also why the pick drew so much heat, since the Canadiens passed on Matvei Michkov and Ryan Leonard. Our read is that the outrage has faded, and Saturday was a good reminder of why. Michkov played on the Flyers’ third line, so Reinbacher, on a third pair, saw him a lot. A right-shot defender who can handle that matchup and come out ahead on the chances is exactly what the plan promised.

A natural right-shot changes how a pair plays. He takes the puck on his forehand along the wall, he makes the first pass out of the zone cleanly, and his partner is not forced onto the wrong side. When a team has to play a left-shot on the right, the puck handling gets harder in every retrieval. That is the structural problem the Canadiens were trying to fix, and it is why Reinbacher is, in our view, more important to the rebuild than any other prospect in the system. Even the hole at second-line center, which Michael Hage may eventually fill, does not weigh more than this one.

How Two Injuries Changed the Plan

The original plan was clean: develop him in Laval, give him a camp, and have him ready for an NHL job by now. Two important injuries over the last few years broke that line. The first cost him development time. The second cost him the rehabilitation, and the Canadiens had to wait for him to be ready. A defenseman who loses games loses repetitions in gap control, retrievals and the first look up the ice, and those only come from playing.

He played two NHL games last season, and that was not enough to show anyone he was ready. He has described the stretch himself as two negative years, and said he put his head down and worked to prove he is the player the club can build on. That attitude is worth noting, because a young player who comes back from two rough years and still talks about proving himself is easier to build around.

A Strong Camp, a Laval Detour and the Call-Up

He had a great training camp, strong enough that it looked like he would make the team. He did not. The Canadiens cut him in favor of Adam Engström, who had nothing left to prove in the AHL, and sent Reinbacher back to Laval. Engström has been very good this season, growing his confidence with the puck and winning more of his minutes than he loses. That was a fair decision. It was also a reminder of how hard the job on the right side is to win.

In Laval he has played 15 games with 3 goals and 4 assists for 7 points, and he has carried heavy ice time. Teammate Brett Berard, who practices against him every day, says what stands out is the quality of his gaps, his speed on his feet and a stick that is hard to beat one-on-one. Those are the three tools a defenseman needs to defend the rush, and they match what we saw in the 10 minutes in Montreal.

Then came the call-up, and the game against Philadelphia. It was his second NHL appearance of this season, after 9:09 in Buffalo on October 17. Head coach Martin St. Louis said afterward, “I thought he played well,” and added that the style the Canadiens want to play suits him, that he can be long defensively, that he will keep getting stronger and that his mind with the puck is already there. St. Louis was careful to say that ten minutes is a small sample, and that his view comes from camp and from watching Laval as well. The message was clear: get him more repetitions.

Two Plays That Showed What He Can Do

Two plays from the third period stood out. The first was a big hit on Noel Acciari, a clean, physical play from a 6-foot-2 right shot who does not shy away from contact. He finished the night with three hits, and that one set the tone for the shifts that followed.

The second was the start of Owen Beck’s goal. Reinbacher won his battle behind the net, a play that decides who gets the puck and who is chasing it, and moved it to Arber Xhekaj. Montreal went the other way from there and scored. A defenseman who wins the puck behind his own net and makes the first pass is doing the job a right-shot defender is supposed to do, and it is the type of play that does not show up on the scoresheet.

What the Numbers Say About His Night

The five-on-five numbers are the cleanest way to read it. In 10:49, Montreal had a 6-3 edge in shots on goal, a 2-0 edge in goals and just over 75 percent of the expected goals. Those are small-sample numbers, and it is worth saying so, since one night does not decide anything. But it is the type of game the Habs needed to see: a defenseman who is not a liability when he is matched against skilled forwards.

Our read is that the first thing it shows is poise. He played within his structure and did not try to do too much. The second is that the NHL environment helps him. He said himself that the game is more structured here, that every player knows his role and where to be, and that it is easier for a defenseman when good players in front of him trust him. That is an argument for more NHL games, not fewer.

What Is Next for Reinbacher and the Habs

The Canadiens expected him to be ready by now if not for the injuries. The club is missing a right-shot defender it can count on for the long term, and Alexandre Carrier is on a final-year contract, which makes the answer more urgent. Reinbacher has to prove it now, while the team is trying to make the playoffs and already has Engström playing well. That makes everything harder, because the more a team has invested in a player, the more opportunity he gets, and he has not had much yet.

The key is to find out whether he is the defenseman the Habs wanted a few years ago, and time is working against them. The good news is that he is healthy and has played good hockey since the start of the season, in Laval and on Saturday. When Matheson returns, Reinbacher may well go back to Laval. If that happens, the Canadiens will still not know whether he can be a long-term answer.

That also leaves a puzzle on the depth chart. Engström is playing well, but he is a left shot on the right side. If Reinbacher is ready, Montreal will have to decide what to do with Engström and Carrier. There is help coming from outside, with Bogdan Konyushkov arriving next season and Bryce Pickford in the system, but neither changes the question for this year.

Our read is that the plan has not failed, it is late. The Canadiens need to see him in more games, with real partners and real matchups, before the trade deadline and well before Carrier’s deal runs out. The loan back to Laval does not change that read: what to watch is whether it is a one-day stop or something longer.

Next Up

Reinbacher and Berard are with Laval for Sunday’s game against Calgary at 3:00 p.m. ET. Montreal then hosts Los Angeles on Monday, November 23 at 7:30 p.m. ET and plays at Colorado on Wednesday, November 25 at 9:30 p.m. ET. Watch whether either player is back with the Canadiens for the Los Angeles game, and what Matheson’s return does to the pairings.

Sources: NHL.com game data and play-by-play; Natural Stat Trick (five-on-five shots, goals and expected goals); post-game comments from the Canadiens locker room as reported by The Athletic; HABSHQ player pages; PuckPedia (contracts).

Get the HABSHQ Newsletter in Your Inbox

Every Monday, the HABSHQ newsletter brings you the full Canadiens, Rocket, Lions and prospects report, our takes, the stats of the week and the preview of the week ahead, straight to your inbox. It is free.

QR code to subscribe to the HABSHQ newsletter
Scan with your phone to subscribe

Get the Habs week in your inbox

Free weekly newsletter from HABSHQ.

More from HABSHQ

Watch the analysis

Coach Frenchy breaks down every Canadiens game live on the Hockey Nation Live Show, with the lines, the numbers and the plays that mattered.

Watch on YouTube

About Coach Frenchy

Coach Frenchy (Pierre) hosts the Hockey Nation Live Show, the daily live Canadiens and NHL commentary show on YouTube. HABSHQ is where he brings the lines, the numbers and the prospects together in one place.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

AboutNewsletterContactTerms and Disclaimer